Do you accept orders over the phone?

Do you accept orders over the phone?

Yes, absolutely! For local delivery or pickup, you may call the store closest to you.

You may reach our teams, by store location, directly via phone at the following numbers:

Bernardsville: (908) 766-6699
Closter: 201-297-5000
Madison: (973) 822-0200

For orders to be shipped, you may call 1-888-99-GARYS (888-994-2797). 

If you have any additional questions - please send us an email at, call us at 1-888-99-GARYS (888-994-2797), or chat with us through the website.

    • Related Articles

    • How do I cancel an order I made online or through the mobile app?

      To cancel your order, please email Please include your name, order number, and phone number where we can reach you if we have any further questions. You can also contact us by phone at 1-888-99-GARYS (888-994-2797) or by chatting ...
    • Can I modify an order once it’s already been placed?

      While we cannot make any guarantees, we will do our best to accommodate order adjustments made within 2 hours after an order has been placed. To edit your order, you may reach out to us through chat or send an email to If you ...
    • What do I need to bring when I pick up my order?

      A customer should print out their order confirmation and bring it with them when they come to pick up their order, along with proper identification. If someone other than the customer is picking up the order, tell us in the notes section upon check ...
    • How do I know when my order will be delivered?

      For local delivery, we typically deliver on the same day as long as your order is placed before 6:00 pm from Monday to Saturday and 3:00 pm every Sunday in all New Jersey store locations. We will send you an email and SMS message with the tracking ...
    • How do I order from Gary's Wine & Marketplace?

      We are pleased to provide you service directly in our stores, online at, or through our mobile app. We currently allow customers to schedule orders for curbside pick-up, local delivery, and/or national shipping. If you have any ...